Ashneil Ajit Singh, 21, was shot and stabbed on November 29th, 2011.
Singh was Edmonton's 44th homicide victim of the year.
Case status remains open and active.
investigators seek iPad as evidence
When police got the call on November 29th, 2011, it marked the first time they had to deal with a homicide in nearly seven weeks. It was the longest break between murders they had all year.
But despite having the victim on the phone as he lay dying in a field somewhere on Edmonton's southwestern edge, investigators didn't catch a break and were unable to put a name to his killer.
It's not often that police get to interview a homicide victim before he dies, to ask such questions as who are you, where are you and who did this to you?
From what was reported, the victim in this case didn't know where he was ... and apparently didn't know – or didn't say – who shot and stabbed him ... or where.
At 12:09 p.m. police received what they term a "trouble unknown" call from a man saying he had been stabbed.
Inspector Brian Nowlan related the nature of the call to a gathering of media.
"He called on his cellphone, he asked for help. But he wasn't able to tell us where he was," Nowlan said. "But via the cellphone we were able to triangulate his position to this area."
It took officers a half hour to locate the man on an abandoned tree-lined farm near 170th Street and 21st Avenue SW.
"He said, 'I've been stabbed.' He didn't know where he was," Nowlan said. "We could tell he was obviously in distress. He just kept saying he's hurt and needs help."
When police found the man he was still holding onto his cellphone, lying on a roadway about 50 feet (15 metres) from his 2003 white Infinity G35 which was parked near several outbuildings.
"He was lying on the road suffering from what appears to be several gunshot wounds and at least one stab wound," Nowlan said.
One early reported indicated the man's throat had been slashed. It wasn't immediately clear whether the man sustained his injuries at the site or elsewhere.
"There's some evidence to show he may have driven there in distress," Nowlan said.
"There's some tracks going through the field that are actually leaving the street, but whether those are actually his or not we have yet to determine.
"We are going to have to trace back the vehicle and see just how exactly it got there."
Police believed the man had been driving northbound on 170th Street before he came to a stop at the farm.
A ground ambulance was first to arrive and an effort was made to stabilise the man.
After assessing the victim's injuries, STARS was called in – see images »
"Our medical crew ... assisted with the care of the patient in the back of a ground ambulance with Alberta Health Services," STARS spokesman Cameron Heke said. "The patient was in critical condition with life-threatening injuries."
The man was flown to the Royal Alexandra Hospital where he was pronounced dead on arrival. Immediately his death was termed suspicious by police.
During most of 2011, Edmonton police made it a habit
of labelling every death they attended as "suspicious" in nature despite obvious circumstances
– including the Rosehill matter that saw two men found dead of gunshot wounds
sitting inside a running SUV in a cemetery.
When news of the death of Russell Haidar broke later on November 12th, 2011 ...
... an Edmonton Journal reporter tweeted his observation on the practice.
A police officer accompanied the victim to hospital, but it wasn't clear if investigators were able to speak to the victim before he passed.
According to CTV Edmonton, in addition to calling police the victim also called his father. No doubt police would go through the cellphone to see what other calls were made on it.
Nowlan said it took officers an hour-and-a-half to go through the half-dozen outbuildings on the farm, looking for weapons and possible suspects – see images »
It was likely that thoughts of March 2005 and Mayerthorpe were running through the minds of police.
"There was nobody else at the scene and we have no witnesses, we have nothing to go by at this time," Insp. Nowlan said.
"We didn't know, upon our response, whether or not that was the scene where this all took place. We had to be very meticulous."
Police had yet track down the owner of the farm, Nowlan said.
A portion of 170th Street was blocked off for several hours as police examined the scene. With an area the size of a farm to cover, they had to return the next day to finish – see images »
If the area seemed vaguely familiar to investigators, it should.
Just seven weeks earlier and three kilometres (two miles) due east, they had attended to another suspicious death that turned out to be two men shot dead inside an SUV in a remote cemetery – read more »
With where the dying man was found being so close to the Rosehill Cemetery, it wasn't difficult to find a person who witnessed police activity in both areas.
"I figured it was kind of the same thing. I could tell it was something serious," construction worker Brian Watters said.
On October 11th, 2011, 26-year-old Trevor James Greenway and 36-year-old Jason Trundle were discovered at 6:30 in the morning with fatal gunshot wounds inside a running late-model black GMC Denali riddled with bullet holes.
Like the scene around the cemetery, the latest victim ended up where new houses were being built.
"It's strange though. It's such a quiet area. I've never heard of anything like that happen here before," Watters said.
Usually residents move out of a neighbourhood due to crime. This latest death might keep them from moving in.
For more, see The Rosehill Double Murder.
On November 30th, the man found at the farm was first identified by friends on social media websites ...
... and later by police as 21-year-old Ashneil Ajit Singh (the latter photograph – issued by police – suggested the man was known to authorities).
An autopsy determined that Singh had died from gunshot wounds. Through a news release, homicide detectives requested the public's assistance.
"If you live in the area of 170 Street and 21 Avenue SW, please check your backyards for any suspicious items like tire marks, blood or bullet casings," Det. Scott Jones wrote.
"If you find anything please do not touch it as it could be evidence. Call police immediately."
Police also said Singh was driving a 2003 white Infinity G35 and they issued a photo of a similar-looking vehicle. Friends of Singh posted a photo of the man's actual car on Facebook.
Police wouldn't say if Singh's death was drug or gang-related, or whether it had any connection to the double murder in the nearby Rosehill Cemetery.
The murder was Edmonton's 44th homicide of the year.
Ashneil Ajit Singh was remembered by friends and family as a man who was loved by many for his big heart and warm smiles – read more »
On a R.I.P Ashneil Singh Facebook memorial page, those who knew the former NAIT student (and more recently, a Grant MacEwan student) posted such tributes as
"Rest in Peace Kiddo ... we will miss you and your warm smile. My Thoughts and Prayers are with the Singh Family Tonight"
"One of the homies shot n' stabbed to death...Ashneil Singh you'll always be remembered...rest in peace brother"
"Wish you were here to see how much lives you've touched Ashey"
"I will never forget you. I will always remember your laugh, smile, and how big of a heart you had"
"I can't believe this still! Miss you so much already!"
"Why does the good ones always leave so early?"
Friends also uploaded their favourite photos, recalling the good times – see images »
News of Singh's death came as a shock to many.
"I go onto Facebook and everybody's status updates said, ‘rest in peace.' When I found out who it was, I couldn't believe it. My jaw dropped," Justin Wehnan said.
The two had first met at Mary Butterworth Junior High in north Edmonton.
"I met him in Grade Seven and since day one, he was always just the most lovable guy. I never knew him to have any enemies. He was the fun guy in the room, the class clown."
They last met at a Method Man concert held at the Edmonton Event Centre in West Edmonton Mall where they unexpectedly bumped into each other at the bar.
"He was like, 'Man, what's your cellphone number? I miss you. I want to get back in touch, we gotta hang out more,' " Wehnan said.
"We gave each other a big hug, talked for a minute. And that was that."
The pair parted with a promise to spend more time together.
"I can't even believe it. I'm still in shock," Wehnan said, adding that it was still difficult to comprehend his friend might have been killed intentionally.
"It didn't seem like he had any problems. He was full of life, full of love. Everything was good. It's too crazy. It's hitting too close to home."
Another man who hadn't seen Singh in a while was Daniel Ferreira.
"We'd crank the music and jam out," he recalled of the weekends he worked with Singh in the car audio section at the Best Buy on 137th Avenue while his friend was still attending M. E. LaZerte High School.
Customers likely also enjoyed the cranked-up ambience of the store as the two got to know each other.
"He was always so outgoing. The kid had a permanent smile going on," Ferreira said.
The co-workers lost touch when Singh left the Best Buy job in 2008. Three years later, Ferreira said the news of his chum's death blew him away.
Fatima Saqqa met Singh at Lazerte and recalled he was always wearing an ear-to-ear grin – even after he'd been in an accident that left his car smashed.
"He was smiling. Can you believe that? Smiling. His heart was so pure and kind," Saqqa said, describing her friend as a "soft-hearted kid" with a love for everybody.
"He is truly an amazing guy. He did not have one hate bone in his body."
 |
Ashneil Singh's funeral was held December 3rd, 2011, at the Park Memorial Funeral Home, 9709 111 Avenue. It was there nearly 400 gathered to pay their respects – read more »
The pews were packed as friends and family took turns at the podium offering tributes and condolences.
Singh was remembered as a loving brother to his siblings, a friend who could be relied upon and a dutiful son.
"Ash was the kind of guy who would offer you his last piece of bread, before taking it himself," a friend said through tears, adding he considered Singh "basically a brother."
The young man was still in shock over events surrounding his friend's death.
"What happened is a tragedy, and Ash, my friend, you will be missed."
The sound of sniffles filled the funeral home when Singh's youngest sister read out her memorial.
"You were the bestest big brother and anything I wanted you gave me," she said. "I love you."
Mourners were asked to remember Singh for his kind heart and ever-present grin.
Investigators seek iPad as evidence
On March 15th, 2012, police announced they were looking for a clue in connection with the death of Ashneil Ajit Singh.
Apple iPad 2
Homicide detectives asked for the public's assistance in locating a white iPad 2 that they believe was purchased by Singh in October 2011, about a month before he died.
"An iPad 2 belonging to Singh that has not yet been accounted for," Det. Scott Jones said in a release to media.
"Singh may have left this electronic device with a friend. This item may assist us with our investigation."
The iPad’s serial number was DN6GCWLDDKPH.
No further details were released and the investigation continues.
Those with information about the iPad or Singh's homicide were asked to contact Edmonton police at 780-423-4567, Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS (8477), or online at www.tipsubmit.com. Tips can also be text messaged.
- In Edmonton: text TIP250 + message and send to CRIMES (274637)
- In Northern Alberta: text TIP205 + message and send to CRIMES (274637)
A confirmation message and unique code number will then be sent. Tipsters can respond by replying.
Media note
While the "anonymous" internet – populated by such social media wesbites as Facebook, Myspace and Twitter – has often been taken to task for hosting and spreading false rumours and innuendo, the online presence of "the mainstream media" can also be a minefield of character assassination and a breeding ground for mindless speculation.
And as Hunter S. Thompson once didn't say, there's also a negative side – read more »
Case in point: the Edmonton Sun, whose reader comments seem to be posted without moderation ... and often without regard to the legalities surrounding libel (let alone the niceties of common decency).
The Sun is not alone in the staging of a theatre that allows desktop (and handheld-device) detectives to snipe from behind an electronic curtain. The Edmonton Journal and the CBC also provide comment space on select stories, making note when inappropriate comments are removed.
What follows is a measure of the double standard at least one print medium seems to enjoy.
In a race to embrace website page views, ethical and journalistic standards seem to be set aside in a bid to out-do others when comments such as the following attached to coverage of Ashneil Singh's murder seem to be allowed to reside online in perpetuity ... or least until their site is redesigned.
Of the several hundred comments still available for perusal here and here, these are but a select few.
The nature of the Sun's online dialogue was observed by at least one person in the Twitterverse.
And about Hunter S. Thompson – read more »
The famous tag line "There's also a negative side" (often attributed to the pioneer of Gonzo journalism) is also a by-product of the internet's propensity for perpetuating falsehoods.
The line is usually associated with criticism about radio, the music industry, show business and the corporate communications industry ... but Thompson never wrote it.
"There's also a negative side" is a punchline often added to this quote from Thompson's 1988 book Generation of Swine: Tales of Shame and Degradation in the '80s, with "TV business" substituted with whatever point is being made.
"The TV business is uglier than most things. It is normally perceived as some kind of cruel and shallow money trench through the heart of the journalism industry, a long plastic hallway where thieves and pimps run free and good men die like dogs, for no good reason."
Not only did Thompson push the envelope with his writings, he often left the planet. And he also defined "fictional journalism," a style that places the writer inside a story, giving up any pretense of objectivity.
Thompson died on February 20th, 2005, at age 67 of a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head.
Months later, as the result of his last wishes, his ashes were packed into fireworks and shot from a 15-storey tower (more about his life and times can be read here).
All the information presented on this page has been compiled primarily from published media reports and should not be interpreted as having legal bearing or other prejudice against the individuals named on this web site.
The Last Link on the Left practices fair presentation and the disclosure of relevant interests.
Mouseover for image credits.